Skip to Content

10 Best Alternatives To Sugar Water That Will Attract Hummingbirds (And 4 Things You Should Never Use)

10 Best Alternatives To Sugar Water That Will Attract Hummingbirds (And 4 Things You Should Never Use)

Ever watched those tiny, jewel-like hummingbirds dart around your garden? These amazing creatures need lots of energy to power their lightning-fast wings.

While traditional sugar water works well, there are actually many other options that can attract these beautiful visitors to your yard. Let’s explore some fantastic alternatives that hummingbirds love, plus a few things you should absolutely avoid for their safety.

1. Natural Flower Nectar

Natural Flower Nectar
© Botanical Interests

Nothing beats what Mother Nature designed! Planting nectar-rich flowers creates a natural buffet that hummingbirds can’t resist.

Red salvias, bee balm, and trumpet vines produce sweet nectar that’s perfectly matched to a hummingbird’s diet. As a bonus, you’ll enjoy beautiful blooms while helping these tiny birds thrive in your garden.

2. Fruit Juice Mixtures

Fruit Juice Mixtures
© Tom’s Guide

Got some leftover fruit juice? Mix one part juice with four parts water for a sweet treat hummingbirds will love.

Apple, grape, or berry juices work wonderfully. Just make sure it’s 100% natural juice without added sugars or artificial ingredients. Remember to clean your feeder daily as fruit juice ferments faster than sugar water.

3. Honey Solution

Honey Solution
© Better With Birds

Raw honey offers a natural alternative with beneficial enzymes and minerals. Mix one part honey with four parts warm water, stirring until completely dissolved.

Honey solutions attract hummingbirds while providing varied nutrients. However, they spoil quickly in hot weather, so change the mixture every other day and clean feeders thoroughly to prevent harmful mold growth.

4. Commercial Nectar Concentrates

Commercial Nectar Concentrates
© Yummy Mummy Kitchen

Ready-made nectar concentrates save time while providing balanced nutrition. Look for brands without artificial dyes or preservatives for the healthiest option.

Simply follow package directions for dilution. These products often include extra vitamins and minerals specifically formulated for hummingbird health. Many bird experts recommend these as they closely mimic natural flower nectar.

5. Maple Syrup Dilution

Maple Syrup Dilution
© Where The Pancakes Are

Pure maple syrup contains minerals and antioxidants that can benefit hummingbirds. Mix one part real maple syrup with five parts water for a sweet alternative.

Never use artificial syrups! Only 100% pure maple syrup is safe. This mixture can be slightly stickier than sugar water, so clean your feeders extra thoroughly to prevent mold growth.

6. Agave Nectar Solution

Agave Nectar Solution
© Happy Gardens

Agave nectar offers a lower glycemic option that’s easy for hummingbirds to digest. Mix one part agave with four parts water for a perfect consistency.

This plant-based sweetener comes from the same family of plants that wild hummingbirds visit in desert regions. Its natural properties resist fermentation slightly longer than sugar water, though you’ll still need regular feeder cleaning.

7. Hummingbird-Friendly Garden Plants

Hummingbird-Friendly Garden Plants
© Patch

Creating a garden filled with tubular flowers provides an all-you-can-eat buffet. Fuchsias, cardinal flowers, and columbines are top picks that produce abundant nectar.

Plant varieties with staggered blooming seasons to provide food throughout summer. Native plants work best as they’ve evolved alongside local hummingbird species. This natural approach requires no feeder cleaning!

8. Fruit Feeders

Fruit Feeders
© House Digest

Fresh fruit attracts both hummingbirds and the tiny insects they eat for protein. Secure orange or banana halves on special fruit feeders or skewer them on branch ends.

The sweet juice from ripening fruit naturally ferments slightly, creating an irresistible scent. As an added bonus, these feeders often attract butterflies too, creating a lively backyard ecosystem.

9. Coconut Water

Coconut Water
© Goodnet.org

Coconut water contains natural electrolytes and minerals that can benefit active hummingbirds. Use it undiluted or mix half coconut water with half regular water.

Choose unflavored, unsweetened varieties without additives. This tropical treat provides potassium and other nutrients that help these high-energy birds maintain their incredible metabolism and flight muscles.

10. Tree Sap Stations

Tree Sap Stations
© birdingthebrookeandbeyond

Mimic nature’s original hummingbird food source by creating artificial sap wells. Some hummingbird species actually evolved to follow sapsuckers, birds that drill holes in trees.

Place shallow dishes of maple sap or very diluted maple syrup near your feeders. This sweet, mineral-rich liquid attracts hummingbirds while providing varied nutrients not found in simple sugar water.

11. NEVER USE: Artificial Sweeteners

NEVER USE: Artificial Sweeteners
© WSAV-TV

Artificial sweeteners provide zero calories while tricking human taste buds. For hummingbirds, this is a disaster! These birds need real sugar’s energy to fuel their incredibly fast metabolism.

Products like aspartame, sucralose, or stevia might seem like healthy alternatives, but they offer no nutritional value to hummingbirds. Using these could actually starve these tiny birds despite their full bellies.

12. NEVER USE: Brown Sugar or Molasses

NEVER USE: Brown Sugar or Molasses
© AOL.com

The iron content in brown sugar and molasses can be harmful to hummingbirds’ delicate systems. These products contain impurities that may cause liver damage over time.

The darker color also makes it harder to spot spoilage or contamination in your feeder. Additionally, the strong flavor can actually repel hummingbirds, who prefer lighter, cleaner-tasting nectars similar to flower nectar.

13. NEVER USE: Food Coloring

NEVER USE: Food Coloring
© Backyard Boss

Skip the red dye despite old advice! Modern research suggests artificial colors may harm hummingbirds’ kidneys and livers over time.

Hummingbirds are attracted to the color red, but that’s what your feeder should be—not the liquid inside. The birds will find clear nectar in a brightly colored feeder just fine without risking their health.

14. NEVER USE: Honey Water Without Boiling

NEVER USE: Honey Water Without Boiling
© A-Z Animals

Raw, unboiled honey can contain bacteria and fungi that cause a deadly tongue infection in hummingbirds called “candidiasis.”

If using honey, always bring the mixture to a boil, then cool completely before filling feeders. Even better, stick with plain sugar water or other alternatives that don’t carry this risk. Hummingbird health should always come first!